
I’m a juke box hero and I’ve got stars in my eyes. Rock Band, by developer Harmonix (Guitar Hero, Karaoke Revolution) is what I consider the true spiritual successor to Guitar Hero II. Forget Guitar Hero III, this monster has it all; drums, bass, guitar, and vocals (and cowbell!). The gameplay is solid (wish I could say the same for the peripherals), a perfect mix of Karaoke Revolution and Guitar Hero with the new drummer mode to tie it all together. The solo career is kind of tired, it has been done three times before. Where the game really shines is as a multiplayer experience, getting the crew together and rocking out in World Tour mode or Band Quickplay.
The World Tour Mode is great fun, you get to name a band, make a logo, and customize your members. The best part is that your friends can make a character on their gamertag (if you didn’t figure it out, this review is for the 360 version) and their characters can play on your console, which sadly is the only way to do World Tour (no online support). This allows your friends characters to earn money (and for them to get precious achievements). This game is all about playing as a group, the achieve five stars in multiplayer you need to work together. This means activating Overdrive (a.k.a. Star Power, which I still find myself saying while playing) together to gain huge multipliers. After playing for almost an entire weekend straight I have learned a few things about playing cooperatively. The drummer is truly the backbone of the band, if he (which would have been me) gets off beat, this can cause the whole band to lose rhythm and play slightly off. Also, the drummer cannot activate Overdrive whenever he pleases, unlike the other members. This can only be done during a drum fill so to get the most out of your Overdrives the drummer needs to watch the other members bars to see when everyone can Overdrive together to get the most out of their power. Another thing is be supportive of your singer, some of the songs are hard or kind of unknown, and sight reading lyrics and pitch is a lot harder than sight reading guitar parts. Also, try not to laugh at the singer, this will make them self conscience and probably sing worse than the may already be doing.

The game play mechanics have not really changed from Guitar Hero to Rock Band, the fret key sequences may be easier in terms of finger dexterity but, the strumming is less forgiving and needs to be far more precise to register. The singing is basically exactly what you would expect from a karaoke game. The drumming is hard. Don’t trust me? Play on hard, for once it is an accurate description. To play on expert you truly need to be an expert and the only people who I have heard of playing on that difficulty so far are real drummers, so yes, the skills of playing the real instrument do transfer for once. Giving all the more reason for the “Why don’t you just play the real thing?” people not to shut the hell up. I have managed to make my way half way through the hard solo career of drummer after a full weeks worth of play. But are you such a rock god that not even expert makes you break a sweat? Think you can play like Geddy Lee of Rush, Sting of The Police, Dave Grohl of the Foo Fighters, or Josh Homme of Queens of the Stone Age? Well step up to the mic and try to sing and play guitar or bass at the same time (luckily the tambourine and cowbell parts done by the vocalist do not punish you for not playing them)!
The peripherals are where my problems with this game arise. They feel cheap, like toys, which is pretty much what they are (except for the mic, it is pretty solid and works great). If you already have the game you have probably already experienced the broken down-strum problem on the new Stratocaster guitar, which really sucks. If you are feeling courageous and you are handy with a Phillips-head screwdriver, don’t send it back because they will likely send you another guitar with the same damn problem. There is an easy fix that involves opening the guitar and tightening a loose tension screw and maybe clearing some gloppy hot glue. Sadly, this does not fix the issue some are having with the Overdrive tilt activation. It doesn’t seem to work when you want it too, which is really sad that this thing has so many issues. The new guitar FEELS great, the neck is thin and the frets are nicely placed, with cool high fret buttons that allow you to entirely hammer on solos. There is also a little effects switch, for use during the solos and when Overdrive is active, that is kind of obtrusive and is easily bumped into a different setting. The loss of the clicking sound on the strum bar may bother some at first, but it is a nice change. This, sadly, is counteracted by the loud ass drums. The sticks that it comes with are crap and the pads are very loud, so forget playing the game at a modest volume, because you won’t be able to hear the sounds of the in game drums over the rap tap tapping of the drum pads. The kick pedal also feels very cheap and people have already had numerous accounts of the base of it snapping right in half. You could try to replace it with a real kick pedal if you are willing to drop some extra cash after your $170 investment, but the point is you shouldn’t need to. They say be gentle but that is really hard while playing “Enter Sandman” on hard and you have to pound on the pedal to play fast enough. Some of you will be happy that the Guitar Hero guitars both work with this game (not if you are a Playstation 3 user, sucks to be you). But, to my dismay, does not work the other way around.
Graphically the game is much better than Guitar Hero 3. The models are more stylized and don’t cross that creepy line between artistic and realistic. The band members interact well with the crowd and each other and have far more diverse animations, you even get multiple stage presence styles to choose from when making you character. The one problem however with the graphics and playing this game with four people is that is you don’t have a widescreen large television everything gets very cramped and can be difficult to see your notes. Touching on what I was saying earlier about the drummer being the bands backbone, it is nice that when playing four player, they put the drummer in the middle of the screen, this makes it easy to see how the rest of your band is doing or where their star power Overdrive meter is at.

The bottom line is this is a great party game with a few hardware flaws that can be frustrating. If you are tired of playing nothing but Wii bowling or only being able to have two people on Guitar Hero at a time at your get togethers, this is a great addition to the party game line up.









Thank you Nate (fellow writer on this here blog) for the tip that K Mart was breaking street date on Mass Effect. I was curious so I checked out the “Big K” near my job on the way home and lo and behold, they had one copy nestled in the glass case just waiting to be taken home by yours truly. This sweet morsel wasn’t supposed to come out for nine more days. However, thanks to K Mart’s inability to read bright orange warning labels on the top of every copy, I now have one in my possession. Hopefully I will be able to clear my schedule of Mario Galaxy and Assassin’s Creed to get some serious play time in and write up a review before the actual street date comes. But listen to me babble on, why aren’t you calling or running to your local K Mart right now to try to get a copy before they realize what the heck they have done!?




